Hello, hello girls! Welcome on this beautiful sunny day! Today I have a really cool post for you – it’s a ranking which is something you guys love and constantly ask me about. This time, we are talking eyebrow mascaras.  I have to say that I really put a lot of effort into checking out which brow mascara is really the best. 🙂 

Best eyebrow mascara RANKING – how did I rate my favorite brow mascaras?

I can assure you that none of the mascaras included in my ranking found themselves there by chance! I thoroughly tested all of them for at least a week. I tested them in different weather conditions. I tested their durability: I went to the gym and checked how each mascara behaves at the end of the day: does my brow makeup still look perfect?  

It was also important to me how to apply a particular brow mascara – this kind of product must be easy to use and ensure beautiful and perfectly shaped eyebrows quickly. I evaluated the brush in each mascara and checked what effects it allowed to achieve. What mattered to me was whether a given eyebrow mascara comes in nice shades that do not look fake. Do they feature good pigmentation and look great in any lighting? The price of a particular brow mascara was also important to me because I don’t like to overpay for my beauty products, and of course, like probably all of you, I would prefer to find a good product at a decent price. 

Unfortunately, I have to add that, no super cheap drugstore brow mascara made it to my best eyebrow mascara ranking. They usually came in terrible shades and their durability was also way from good.  I think there is no need to waste time on products like those. But without further ado… here is my ranking of the best eyebrow mascaras – hope you enjoy it!

Best brow mascara – beauty RANKING  

PLACE 1. NANOBROW SHAPE MASCARA 

best brow mascara for sparse brows

This eyebrow mascara comes in a large size, features beautiful shades, and is equipped with a phenomenal brush. It is the best brow makeup product I can think of. It makes your eyebrows look elegantly brushed-up, shaped, and beautifully filled in. This brow-styling mascara gives great effects: no sticky finish or clumps. The consistency is perfect for weeks, the brush coats each hair precisely, adding definition and a thicker look. It makes eyebrows look visually thicker and comes in beautiful shades. Nanobrow Shape Mascara is a recommended brow mascara with excellent reviews and is trending in the world of makeup products. And on top of that, its price is really a bargain for such high quality and efficiency.

PLACE 2. LANCOME SOURCILS STYLER BROW MASCARA

I like this brow mascara mainly because of its cool brush. It’s unusual, made of silicone, and cone-shaped… it resembles a pear shape and it works great! For me at least, as in the case of my friend, it stained her skin, so all in all, it all depends on how much makeup skills you have and how thick your eyebrows are. However, this eyebrow mascara certainly won’t disappoint you if you’re hoping for long-wear effects. Unfortunately, this is not a cheap brow mascara… just this one is probably the most expensive mascara in my ranking.

PLACE 3. BENEFIT COSMETICS GIMME BROW MASCARA 

I know this is the mascara loved by influencers and that it’s eagerly recommended. But remember that most users use it for bolder, evening looks. This mascara ensures a super strong effect. Sure, it looks cool on not very defined eyebrows, but if someone has thick, bushy, or normal eyebrows, it may create a slightly overdrawn, cartoonish look. This is a good eyebrow mascara for fans of formulas enriched with fibers which ensure the eyebrows gain volume. The brush glues brow hairs together a bit, and you need to brush out your eyebrows after the application.

PLACE 4. URBAN DECAY BROW MASCARA ENDOWED

Hmmmm… I’m not really convinced about this eyebrow mascara… It’s expensive and comes in a small size, in addition, in my opinion, it’s not cool that the product is double-sided – only one side contains eyebrow mascara, while there is a transparent brow gel on the other end, which is completely unnecessary for me, because you generally define your eyebrows with one or the other. It would be better if there was a brow pencil on the other end, which at least can be used to emphasize the lower bottom brow line… Well, and in the end, you just get less brow mascara. However, you have to admit that the product works beautifully, although it seems that at the end of the day, it may smudge a little

PLACE 5. KIKO MILANO EYEBROW MASCARA 

Another brow mascara enriched with fibers in my ranking. It’s pretty decent, but is it the best eyebrow mascara? Well, in my opinion, it didn’t even deserve the podium. But still, compared to the dozen I tested, this one did quite well… I think that women who like the so-called glossy brow effect will be satisfied. I know that many of you associate this kind of shape with healthy eyebrows, but in my opinion, they do not look nice in any light. I definitely prefer powdery mascaras, but as I mentioned, this is a subjective feeling. 

Eyebrow mascara effects – how does a brow mascara work?

Did you know that eyebrow mascara is one of the most popular makeup products? That’s because it gives such great makeup effects quickly, and it’s easy to use. With a good brow mascara, eyebrows are clearly defined and gain a beautiful color and a WONDERFUL volume. A good eyebrow mascara gives brows a thicker look, filling in the gaps between brow hairs. And all this in a matter of seconds, with just a few brush strokes. A brow-styling mascara is ideal for anyone who doesn’t have the time or skills to fill in their eyebrows with, for example, tricky-to-use brow pomade. In addition, brow mascara mascara does a great job of styling the arches, ensuring a neat and really chic and elegant look. Let me tell you: a good eyebrow mascara is a real beauty must-have!

Mistakes in choosing eyebrow mascara

I guess these are worth mentioning as it turns out that many people still make them. Did you know that when choosing an eyebrow mascara we very often go for the wrong shade? It is often too dark and does not look nice on the eyebrows. So remember that a good eyebrow mascara should be in a shade close to or lighter than the shade of your eyebrows.  Another disadvantage is a bad brush: if you choose a brow mascara wand  with widely-spaced bristles, you can be sure that this mascara will sooner or later begin to glue your eyebrows together and, instead of  beautiful makeup, you will get an overdrawn effect.

Eyebrow mascara ranking… summary

Well, that’s it… summing up my best eyebrow mascara ranking in a few sentences, I have to admit that I’m really happy that I managed to find the best eyebrow mascara at a great price! I can honestly say that the results of my ranking surprised me because I expected crazy expensive mascaras to be at the top… but in the end, they did not rank that high. This is very comforting as it proves that a good brow mascara does not have to cost a fortune. I’m really glad to have found the best brow mascara for myself at a good price that gives great makeup results. Have you also found the best brow-styling mascara for yourself in my ranking? I hope so! Let me know which brow mascara is your favorite! Until the next one, dear readers! Ciao!